When I worked at U-92, our mid-day jock and my good friend, Al Cruise, was a huge Kennedy Assassination buff. He had hours, probably days worth of documentaries, shelves of books, and a zillion opinions.
He and I didn’t agree on everything regarding the assassination, but one area where we concurred is that Oliver Stone’s film “JFK” is brilliant. Hugely full of shit, but an awesome piece of filmmaking.
“JFK” is mostly based on “On the Trail of the Assassins,” by former New Orleans DA, Jim Garrison. Garrison was–and remains–the only prosecutor to bring a trial in the assassination of John Kennedy. Garrison charged New Orleans businessman Clay Shaw with conspiracy to murder the President.
See, Shaw supposedly also went by the alias Clay Bertrand, and was a homosexual who teamed up with the FBI, CIA, militant Cubans, the Mafia, and/or Las Vegas entertainer, Liberace.
Okay, Liberace wasn’t involved. Nor, if you believe “JFK,” was Lee Harvey Oswald. Oswald, to believe this film, was a CIA operative whose time in the USSR was a spy mission. The CIA created Oswald, then set him up to be the fall guy for the JFK assassination.
I’ve seen this film probably 20 times in the 20 years since its release, and I still can’t see any logic in prosecuting Clay Shaw. Even if he had known Oswald during Oswald’s New Orleans summer, there’s never proof that Shaw was involved. At least not that I can see.
Last week, I wrote about “Judgment at Nuremberg,” which was a fictional story set in a real event. Oliver Stone isn’t saying this is the definitive truth about the JFK Assassination.
This is fortunate, since so much of “JFK” is demonstrably untrue. characters who never existed did things that never happened.
But what a freakin’ ride. This film is chockablock with amazing performances. Kevin Costner plays Jim Garrison. Sissy Spacek* is his wife. Jack Lemmon**, Joe Pesci*, Walter Matthau*, Tommy Lee Jones**, Lauri Metcalf***, Ed Asner*****, Kevin Bacon, Michael Rooker, et al, are all brilliant. (The * represents an acting Oscar or Emmy, and I got bored before I finished looking them all up)
The Babe Ruth performance on this acting Murderer’s Row is from Donald Sutherland*, who plays “X,” a mysterious stranger who appears for a 15 minute scene, and explains all manner of chicanery, flimflammery, asshattery, you name it. It’s brilliant.
Even John Larroquette, winner of five Emmys and a Tony, has a five minute role as a talk show host.
There’s a lot of talk in “JFK,” a huge amount of talk. But the film is engrossing, sharp, and beautifully made.
Oh, John Candy is great too.
The factual liberties don’t take away from the film’s power and brilliance.
The main thing that detracts here is that the only version available on DVD is the Director’s Cut, an oxymoron if ever there was one: Stone took a 189 minute film, and added nearly 20 more minutes. Ironically, one of “JFK”s two Oscars?
Grade: A- (theatrical release)/B (Director’s Cut)
(Notes: check here for a nice 100 point debunking of “JFK”; also, as a result of this film, Congress acted to allow closer examination of JFK Assassination documents)
There’s an episode of “Quantum Leap” that’s a direct rebuttal to this. The creator had actually met Oswald when they were both Marines, and was completely unsurprised when LHO was revealed to be the shooter, as even on short acquaintance LHO was both batshit insane and capable of making the shot.
I saw that one! Didn’t Scott Bakula leap into LHO, then he was begging to leap out of him before the shot?
Gerald Posner wrote a book called “Case Closed.” He goes through each of the conspiracy theories and debunks them. LHO was a great shot, according to his shooting range scorecards.
I just think people have a hard time thinking one loon could kill “their” president.
Yes, he did (and he did).
Nobody back then wanted to accept the one guy theory. Nowadays, we realize the lone crazy is all too common.
I can’t stand when films play so loose with facts, because the sad part is given the state of literacy in the United States, too many people will believe this load of crap as “fact”.
Just because you want it to be true, Ollie, doesn’t mean it is. Haven’t watched his 9/11 flick either. I bet the CIA did that too.
I agree, in that if people believe that film is the truth (and there’s no disclaimer), there would be a higher moron factor than we need.
I watched JFK, then watched literally weeks worth of documentaries about the assassination. Most people, sadly, didn’t have as well-equipped a mentor as I did.
For it’s fullofshittedness, it’s still a lovely piece of filmmaking.